From: Richard S. Holmes (rsholmes_at_MailBox.Syr.Edu)
Date: Tue May 27 2003 - 07:31:37 PDT
Ed Murphy <emurphy42_at_socal.rr.com> writes: > > Ha ha ha ha ha, I kill myself! > > I wish you would, you smart-ass. > > All future rules must include an /ad hominem/ attack. And if you don't > know what that is, because you don't speak Latin... there are no words. > > -- > Rule Date: 2003-05-27 04:21:36 GMT VALIDITY: Quotes the preceding rule and indicates assent, but is "Ha ha ha ha ha, I kill myself!" sarcasm, and is "I wish you would, you smart-ass" a comment on the sarcasm of that sentence? I'm not at all sure it is, but it's a grey area and I'll give the benefit of the doubt. VALID. STYLE: I'd be inclined to award higher style if the above grey area had been avoided and if the restriction were one that hadn't been proposed twice already. +1.0. -- - Rich Holmes Syracuse, NY "We're waist deep in the Big Muddy And the big fool says to push on." -- Pete Seeger -- Rule Date: 2003-05-27 14:31:56 GMT
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Thu Nov 24 2011 - 10:48 PST