193:2 VALID

From: Mary K. Kuhner (mkkuhner_at_eskimo.com)
Date: Sat Sep 21 2002 - 08:46:42 PDT

James Willson <jkvw3_at_yahoo.com> writes:

>I hereby vote for Ed Murphy as Comittee Clown.
>This is not without consequence, as for any given elected office, fantasy rule,
>and comittee member, that comittee member holds that office with respect to
>that fantasy rule if and only if that comittee member received no fewer votes
>in prior fantasy rules for that office than any other member.  So, Ed Murphy
>will be the Clown with respect to the next valid fantasy rule.
>Any comittee member authoring a rule who holds an office with respect to that
>rule must perform the duties of that office in authoring that rule, else the
>rule is invalid.  For example, the Clown must make a joke.
>Similarly, if a comittee member performs the duties of an office while
>authoring a rule, yet does not hold that office with respect to that rule, then
>that rule is invalid.
>A mouthful, perhaps, but good elections require precision, as Joshua would

>Rule Date: 2002-09-21 07:16:34 GMT

Ruling: Valid
Style: 0

The next-to-last paragraph inspires some doubt in the Judge's mind,
and the rule is also a bit lengthy.

Mary Kuhner (Storm) mkkuhner_at_eskimo.com

Rule Date: 2002-09-21 15:47:22 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Thu Nov 24 2011 - 10:48 PST